Adam Magazine on the Crazy Years

Looting, killing and raping -- by twisting their words they call it "empire"; and wherever they have created a wilderness they call it "peace" -- Tacitus

Thursday, September 15

John Roberts -- Weasel

Confirmation Report - Oh, the humanity! By Dahlia Lithwick: "Senate Democrats have had it up to here with 'John Roberts the lawyer.' And it's hard to blame them. John Roberts the lawyer won't answer any questions. At least, as the sole arbiter of what questions he'll answer, he's doing a rather phenomenal job of broadly defining great classes of questions as unanswerable:

* He won't answer questions about any case currently pending before the Supreme Court (abortion, right-to-die);
* He won't answer questions about any case that might someday conceivably be pending before the Supreme Court (separation of powers, contested presidential elections);
* He won't answer questions he's decided on the court of appeals (since they may someday conceivably be pending before the Supreme Court);
* He won't answer questions about prior nominees (Robert Bork) because that is not appropriate;
* He can't answer questions about general legal doctrine because they are too general;
* He can't answer questions about specific legal doctrine because they are too specific;
* He can't answer questions about his early memos because a robot wrote them."

1 Comments:

At 4:19 PM, Blogger TL Patten said...

Hmm. Here's a question Mr. Roberts should be able to answer then:

"Given your lack of ability to express an opinion on any matter put to you, why should we find you capable of expressing an opinion for the Supreme Court?"

 

Post a Comment

<< Home